Discogs vs eBay: Which Is Better for Selling Records?
Discogs charges 9% and reaches collectors who search for exact pressings. eBay charges 13.6% and reaches everyone else. Here's when each one wins.
Discogs is usually the better place to sell a record whose value depends on the exact pressing: buyers search by release, the fee is 9%, and past sale prices are shown on every release page. eBay is better when you want the widest audience or an auction: it reaches buyers who do not use Discogs, at a 13.6% fee for vinyl. Many sellers list on both and remove the record from one site as soon as it sells on the other.
This comparison is written by record sellers who list on Discogs and Etsy. Fees were checked in October 2026; confirm them on each site before you price.
Discogs vs eBay at a glance
| Discogs | eBay | |
|---|---|---|
| Who buys there | Collectors looking for a specific release | A general audience, including casual buyers |
| How buyers search | By release, catalogue number, pressing | By artist and title, with photos |
| Selling fee (US) | 9% of item and shipping (min $0.10, max $150 per item), plus payment processing | Vinyl: 13.6% of the total including shipping and tax (12.7% with a Basic Store or above), plus $0.30–$0.40 per order |
| Selling formats | Fixed price, offers | Fixed price, offers, auctions |
| Price research | Last sold date and low, median and high from recent sales on each release page | Sold listings filter |
| Listing effort | Pick the exact release, grade, set a price | Write a title and description, add photos |
| Main risk | Disputes if the release or grade is wrong | Higher fees; buyers less familiar with grading |
When Discogs is the better choice
- The record's value depends on the pressing: originals, regional issues, promos, 12-inch singles, niche genres.
- You can identify the exact release, including the matrix or runout where versions look alike.
- You want buyers who already know what they are looking at and do not need the record explained.
- The record is worth enough that the fee difference matters. On a $56 sale (a $50 record with $6 shipping), Discogs takes $5.04 and eBay takes $8.02.
When eBay is the better choice
- The record is rare and in demand, and you want collectors to bid against each other. An auction can finish above the usual Discogs price.
- The buyer is more likely to search by artist than by catalogue number: famous albums, gifts, box sets.
- You are selling a lot (a whole crate, a run of one artist) rather than single records. Discogs listings are one release at a time.
- You want the larger audience and accept the higher fee for it.
What each one costs on the same record
| Sale | Discogs fee | eBay fee |
|---|---|---|
| $15 record + $6 shipping | $1.89 | $3.26 |
| $50 record + $6 shipping | $5.04 | $8.02 |
Discogs figures exclude payment processing, which is charged separately. eBay figures use the 13.6% rate for sellers without a Basic Store and assume no sales tax; tax added at checkout increases the amount the fee is calculated on.
Using both without selling the same record twice
Every used record is a single item, so a listing on two sites needs one rule: when it sells on one, it comes off the other the same day.
- Keep one inventory list with a storage location for each record.
- Check both marketplaces at least daily.
- Adjust the price for each site's fee if you want the same amount in your pocket from either.
- If two buyers pay for the same record, refund one immediately and apologise.
Before listing anywhere, identify the pressing: our guide on how to tell if a record is a first pressing covers the labels and runout details that separate versions, and how to price records shows how to turn sold prices into an asking price. For Etsy, Facebook Marketplace and local shops, see the best place to sell vinyl records.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to sell records on Discogs or eBay?
Discogs is usually better for collectable pressings, because buyers search for exact releases and the 9% fee is lower. eBay is better for auctions on rare records, for lots, and for reaching buyers who search by artist. Many sellers use both.
Are Discogs fees lower than eBay fees?
Yes. Discogs charges 9% of the item price and shipping. eBay charges 13.6% of the total for vinyl records (12.7% with a Basic Store or above) plus $0.30 to $0.40 per order. On a $50 record with $6 shipping that is $5.04 on Discogs and $8.02 on eBay, before Discogs payment processing.
Do records sell for more on eBay or Discogs?
It depends on the record. Common collectable pressings tend to sell at similar prices on both. Rare records in high demand can sell for more in an eBay auction, where several buyers bid against each other.
Can I list the same record on Discogs and eBay?
Yes, but each used record is a single item, so remove it from the other site as soon as it sells. Keep one inventory list and check both sites daily.
Which is easier for a beginner, Discogs or eBay?
eBay is easier to start on, because you describe the record in your own words. Discogs asks you to match the exact release and grade it to a standard scale, which takes longer at first but leads to fewer questions from buyers.